American Idol hopefuls: they may not be models of morality, but should we hold it against them?
Check out this new story about American Idol (one of my TV obsessions) (passed on to me by one of my teammates, thanks Irene!) It seems one of the contestants, Scott Savol, was once arrested for domestic violence. The news story gave more details about what happened.
I’m not surprised that he is not disqualified from the competition. I mean when has America ever really cared whether their Idols real lives are moral and good? Look at the people who have once been “American idols” and how they have turned out! Bill Clinton, Michael Jackson, O.J. Simpson, and many others! How many rappers, pro football players, actors have been arrested for breaking laws? Too many!
If anything, this might make him more qualified to be an American Idol (In a sick, backwards kind of way, of course)! America’s music world and culture has never really made morality or goodness a qualification for pop stardom, just talent and sexiness. I don’t really expect them to start now. And to really be nit-picky, I suppose if we were to go digging into all of the competitors pasts, we could find things that they have done that are wrong or immoral or bad, things that they probably regret.
Even if American Idol isn’t just about singing and looking good, is it fair or right to hold Scott’s past against him in this competition, just because his past happened to make the news for America to hear?
I think NOT.
We don’t know how he feels about his past. Maybe he’s really sorry about what he did. I hope that this news story, in an attempt to get attention (in the media’s typical news fashion of digging up all possible dirt on everyone involved) doesn’t ruin his chances at becoming American Idol by unfairly showing him in a negative light where they haven’t shown the other contestants. It adds a bias against him where we have no information on the other contestants’ lives. We shouldn’t hold it against him, only how well or poorly he performs and sings.
Just as a disclaimer, please do NOT think that I am in any way saying that I think domestic abuse is OK or should not be punished. I am totally and completely against it, and men who do such things make me sick. But what I am saying is that it is unfair for the media to run such a story that will unfairly represent a contestant in such a competition. And it is unfair for us to see one such piece of information about only ONE contestant’s bad past, and to decide to let that sway our vote against him in favor of other contestants who we know EVEN LESS about!
Give Scott the benefit of the doubt. Vote for him based on his singing and performing, not his past actions that you don’t really know anything about! Do the right thing even though the media hasn’t. Shame on you media.
EDIT 4/1: I found on the Entertainment Weekly site an article with this quote:
Fox issued a statement saying that Savol would stay. “Scott Savol was forthcoming to the American Idol producers and the network regarding his misdemeanor,'’ the statement read. ‘’After reviewing the facts, in which the charges were reduced to disorderly conduct, we felt that considering Scott’s honesty and his remorse, the situation did not warrant his disqualification.”
So they say in this one, where the other selectively quoted the FOX statement, that it was because of his honesty AND remorse, so we know that he is remorseful. I’m somewhat pleasantly surprised that FOX even cared that he was remorseful, although, I guess this is a family show?
I guess the point that this makes to me is that American Idol, although it claims to, doesn’t REALLY represent the real dynamics and values of the real pop star culture these days. It’s too honest, too virtuous, too family friendly. But then again, maybe this shows a change in pop culture these days. But, most likely, and unfortunately, not. Once the American Idol wannabe winner becomes a real idol, no one will probably care whether he or she is a big jerk, only whether his or her music is fun, sounds good, and makes people happy.
I hope I have challenged you and I have convinced you not to let this sway your vote against him and to not encourage others to either. He deserves this chance, and he is probably hoping that he can finally put his past behind him. We owe it to him to be fair in our voting America!
